Two new studies out this month suggest the answer is yes, that
watching pornography can have a detrimental effect on people's
perception of women and reinforce negative stereotypes.
A new study in the Psychology of Women Quarterly shows that both men and
women who watch porn are less likely to support affirmative action for
women. The study is fascinating because it shows a decrease in support
of affirmative action for women over time if people watch porn, even
when controlling for political and religious views. The data indicated
that "prior pornography viewing predicted subsequent opposition to
affirmative action," but "prior opposition to affirmative action did not
predict subsequent pornography viewing." This suggests people didn't
watch porn that objectified women because they had pre-existing negative
attitudes; rather, porn helped develop this negative change in their
views of women.
Another study published in the Journal of Communications
shows that watching porn correlates to an immediate increase in sexist
attitudes, but only in a subgroup of men who are considered low in
"agreeableness" (meaning they were generally cold, unfriendly, and
hostile). After exposing men and women to hardcore pornography, only men
in this subgroup illustrated an increase in sexist attitudes.
The researchers behind this study emphasize that porn does not cause,
so much as reinforce, the sexist attitudes apparent in this subgroup.
"If these men already have these kinds of beliefs, but they are more
dormant, porn appears to prompt these in their conscious minds," Neil Malamuth, a co-author of the study and psychology professor at UCLA, tells Cosmpolitan. "These men already have these tendencies; porn adds fuel to the fire."
However, both of these studies are skirting a key issue: It may not
be pornography itself that is the problem, but rather the types of porn
people are watching (and using in these experiments).
"I have a real issue when people talk about porn as if it was one
big, homogenous mass. It's like talking about literature as just one
type," says Cindy Gallop, the founder and CEO of Make Love Not Porn,
a website dedicated to promoting more realistic sexual depictions in
adult films. Rather than make a "blanket statement" that porn
contributes to negative views of women, Gallop "wants people to think
more about the landscape of pornography" and consider the "porn about
people having a great time in great ways."
Erin Gloria Ryan at Jezebel
agrees that the problem may well be the kind of porn people are
watching, rather than something inherently bad about pornography. "That
viewing certain types of porn causes people to subconsciously look down
on women isn't surprising," she writes.
But remember: There is also "feminist porn,"
adult films that challenge traditional gender roles and provide a lot
more control (assuming they don't want to be dominated) to all the
performers in it. There is plenty of porn that doesn't subjugate women
or portray them solely as vessels of male sexual gratification.
Still, sexist porn is still quite prevalant, and that may be because
the porn industry is still mostly led by men. "Any industry that is
predominantly driven by men and is targeting men, inevitably produces
output that is sexist," Gallop says. "If we had an industry that was
50-50 equal and that was formed, driven, and influenced by women, it
would be a different picture."
source: theweek.com
0 comments:
Post a Comment